
Three years ago this week, a woman named Danielle walked up to what was left of her Kia Sorento, which had caught fire the day before, and filmed herself pulling a Stanley Quencher out of the cupholder. The video runs for fourteen seconds. She says everybody worries about whether a Stanley spills and nobody asks whether it melts, then shakes the cup so you can hear what's inside. “Fire yesterday,” she says. “Still has ice in it.”
By the weekend close to 60 million people had watched it, a number that eventually passed 90 million. The comments mostly agreed that Stanley could spend whatever it liked and never make a better ad.
Stanley seems to have agreed. Within days its president, Terence Reilly, posted a reply offering new cups and, remarkably, a replacement car. Danielle ended up with a 2024 Mazda CX-90.
It usually gets told as a story about a marketer who moves fast, which it is. But by November 2023 Stanley had spent three years turning a workman's flask company into something people collected, and the most famous thing to emerge from that effort was filmed by a customer in a junkyard, about a fire the company had nothing to do with.
Stanley had already given up on the cup
The Quencher was only in Danielle's car because other customers had rescued it. Launched in 2016 as a 40-ounce tumbler for Stanley's traditional outdoor audience, it hadn't sold particularly well. By 2019 the company had stopped restocking it.
Three women running a shopping blog called The Buy Guide saw something different. One of them, Ashlee LeSueur, had been recommending the Quencher since 2017. When it began disappearing from shelves, they bought 5,000 directly from Stanley and sold every one in five days.
In January 2020 they persuaded Stanley's leadership that this wasn't camping gear but an everyday cup for women. Stanley brought it back in more colours and gave The Buy Guide a share of sales.
Reilly arrived later that year from Crocs and built on what they had discovered. Limited colours, creator partnerships and carefully timed drops helped revenue grow from $73 million in 2019 to $402 million in 2022.
It was skilled marketing, and the reason Danielle owned the cup in the first place. But the idea came from three customers, and the video that capped it came from a fourth.
Watch those fourteen seconds again. Danielle doesn't mention colours or limited drops. She shows a steel cup keeping ice through a fire, essentially the same promise William Stanley made for his vacuum bottle in 1913.
New Balance waited thirty years, then printed the joke
New Balance had to wait considerably longer for its moment. The 990 launched in 1982 at $100, an unprecedented price for a running shoe. It was designed for serious runners who valued performance over appearance.
Instead, two unexpected audiences adopted it. Middle-aged men appreciated its comfort and discretion. In Washington, D.C., hustlers wore it for almost the opposite reason: it was the most expensive sneaker around, and everyone who mattered knew it.
The same grey shoe meant your dad in one place and money in another. New Balance hadn't planned either.
The dad version eventually went national. In 2013, Saturday Night Live parodied New Balance as shoes made for running but “worn by chubby white guys.” Around the same time, the concept of normcore helped turn deliberately ordinary clothing into a fashion statement.
New Balance didn't redesign the 990 to escape its reputation. When the fifth version launched in 2019, its advertisement showed a grey shoe beneath one line: “Worn by supermodels in London and dads in Ohio.”
The company hadn't invented the dad joke or put the shoes on supermodels. It simply acknowledged what had happened.
Last year New Balance sold $9.2 billion in shoes and clothing, up 180% since 2020. Retail distribution and competitors' decisions helped, certainly, but New Balance was already carrying a cultural meaning people recognised.
Crocs spent years trying to sell anything but the clog
Crocs is the company that tried to escape the product that eventually saved it.
In 2007 it sold $847 million of foam clogs. A year later its shares had collapsed, and by 2010 Time had named the clog among the fifty worst inventions.
Crocs responded by trying to become a conventional footwear company. It introduced golf shoes, heels and dress shoes, but revenue barely moved between 2011 and 2017.
Andrew Rees, who became chief executive in 2017, decided the company had been wrong to abandon its most recognisable product. He closed stores, eliminated distractions and put the classic clog back at the centre. Reilly, then chief marketing officer, launched the “Come As You Are” campaign with Drew Barrymore.
Days later, Demna Gvasalia sent models down Balenciaga's Paris runway wearing Crocs on ten-centimetre platforms, in yellow and bubblegum pink.
It was an official collaboration, but Crocs couldn't have arranged for one of fashion's most influential designers to decide that a foam clog was exactly what the season needed. Christopher Kane had already featured Crocs on a runway the previous year. Something was happening beyond the company's control.
When Balenciaga's version went on pre-order for $850, it sold out within hours.

Courtesy Balenciaga
The Crocs brand has grown for eight consecutive years, reaching $3.3 billion last year. Rees and Reilly deserve credit for ensuring the company was ready when demand arrived. But the cultural shift began somewhere else.
A forty-year-old paper saw this coming
In 1986, Canadian anthropologist Grant McCracken published “Culture and Consumption” in the Journal of Consumer Research. His argument was that products don't arrive with meaning already inside them. Meaning exists in culture, in our ideas about age, class, work and taste, and moves into products through different channels.
Two of those channels were advertising and what he called the fashion system: designers, journalists and influential groups whose tastes others eventually adopt. He also described possession rituals, the ways consumers make products meaningful by displaying, discussing and photographing them.
Look at these three stories through that framework.
The hustlers in D.C., Saturday Night Live and Balenciaga were part of the fashion system. Danielle was performing a possession ritual for 90 million people. Advertising, the channel companies can actually buy, arrived afterwards to confirm what culture had already decided.
What's striking is that Stanley had stopped restocking the Quencher and Crocs had tried to escape the clog. In two cases, the product culture eventually wanted was precisely the one management had considered a problem.
A positioning document is a guess about what a product means. The people who buy it are the ones who find out.
The same playbook, without the fire
You could argue that good marketers create these moments. Conveniently, there's been a test involving the same marketer.
In April 2024, Reilly left Stanley to lead HEYDUDE, the lightweight footwear brand Crocs had acquired for roughly $2.5 billion. He brought the familiar playbook: celebrity partnerships, TikTok Shop and stronger cultural visibility.
He signed Sydney Sweeney and nearly doubled awareness among women in eighteen months. Yet revenue fell from $949 million in 2023 to $715 million in 2025, while Crocs wrote $737 million off the brand's value.
Some of that decline was deliberate, reflecting changes in wholesale distribution and marketing spending. And two weeks ago, Crocs reported that HEYDUDE had returned to growth, with third-quarter revenue up 6%.
That's not failure. A shrinking brand is growing again after patient work. But compare that 6% with the year Quencher sales rose 275%.
The difference is what nobody at head office can manufacture on demand. Colours, creators and collaborations make products easier for culture to discover. They cannot guarantee what happens next.
HEYDUDE is still waiting for its fire.
The two that lasted never changed
Stanley is now discovering that cultural meaning can disappear as quickly as it arrives. At its peak, the Quencher represented more than three quarters of its business. Today it's closer to 40%, partly because other categories have grown.
New Balance and Crocs have held on to their moments longer, perhaps because of what their meanings were attached to.
The Quencher's excitement depended on the next colour, and anything exciting because it's new must keep being new.
The 990, meanwhile, has remained essentially the same grey shoe since 1982. The Crocs clog has never stopped looking strange. Culture can rediscover either product whenever it likes and find it waiting.
What was in the cup
Go back to the junkyard, and consider who actually put what into that cupholder.
The cup was there because three women persuaded Stanley not to abandon it, and a president was sensible enough to listen. The ice survived because of technology developed in 1913.
But the phone, the joke and the decision to film a burned-out car were Danielle's.
She later said she wouldn't drink from the cup again. She would keep it in her garage as a souvenir.
Somewhere in those fourteen seconds, the tumbler had become something more than a product. It was now part of her story, and no brand team could have written that for her.
Stanley made the cup. Stanley made the ice possible. The smartest thing it did was recognise that the rest belonged to somebody else, and say thank you with a Mazda.

